Superbowl XLII: A Giant Upset

New York Giants 17 - 14 New England Patriots

After each side contested their 19th game of the season, it was the end. For the New England, their "Pursuit of Perfection" had reaped no reward. They were not to leave Glendale, Arizona with the Vince Lombardi trophy. Their record, a commendable 18-1 meant nothing after the end of the Superbowl on Sunday night. The New York Giants had caused an almighty upset. The Giants became the first NFC Wildcard to win a Superbowl, and in doing so ended the Patriots dream of emulating the 1972 Miami Dolphins, who went 16-0, and the season unbeaten. The heartbreak of the Patriots and the jubilation of the Giants highlighted both the pros and the cons of the system in which American Football teams compete.

The action was intense, and the 7-3 scoreline in favour of the Patriots at half-time only told half the story. The Giants were getting a lot of the ball and were rattling New England. Suddenly, the league's most lethal combination of QB Tom Brady and Wide-Receiver Randy Moss, did not look so lethal. The Giants' defence was holding out and keeping the dream alive. New England looked to have won it when that lethal combination previously mentioned, managed to score a touchdown. Each team's entire season went down to five minutes of football. The Patriots stifled the Giants' Offense before Eli Manning produced a piece of magic that will be shown in Superbowl showreels for years to come. It looked like the Giants Quarter-Back had been sacked (something the Giants managed to do Manning's New England counterpart, Tom Brady five times), but somehow managed to squirm free before throwing the ball to David Tyree, who managed to catch the ball by holding it against his helmet. Manning then found Plaxico Burress to make it 17-14 New York. The Giants held on and managed to win their third championship.

While the Giants celebrated an improbable victory, the Patriots had to accept their first defeat of the season. They had saved their worst performance for the last game, the one that mattered most, and this is the fatal flaw in the league structure of NFL. As the author of this article has been brought up on a diet of Premier League football, a league in which the best team undoubtedly wins by having the best record over the course of the season. On Sunday night, the best team in the 2007 NFL Season did not win the championship. A plucky outsider managed to force their way through the post season and triumph. This is also one of the joys of the structure and makes the Superbowl such a spectacle and a joy to watch. The Giants deserve their victory, but there was no doubt in who was the best team in the NFL this season.